Algebraic geometry

Hilbert schemes of points

The Hilbert scheme Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) is the space of zero-dimensional subschemes of length nn in the plane: sets of nn distinct points, and their limits as points collide. Each is cut out by an ideal I⊂C[x,y]I\subset\CC[x,y] with dim⁡C[x,y]/I=n\dim\CC[x,y]/I=n, so Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) is also the space of these ideals. The points in the figure are real.

Points

The monomial ideals in , by their number of rows

Presentation of the ideal

The ideal and its staircase

    The ideal II consists of the polynomials ff that vanish at every chosen point: f(p)=0f(p)=0. At a point of multiplicity kk along a curve γ\gamma, with γ(0)=p\gamma(0)=p, ff vanishes to order kk along the curve: f(γ(s))=O(sk)f(\gamma(s))=O(s^k). At a double point with direction vv, this means f(p)=∂vf(p)=0f(p)=\partial_vf(p)=0.

    The monomials xaybx^ay^b are ordered by their weight w1a+w2bw_1a+w_2b, ties broken by the power of yy, for the weight ww on the dial beside the staircase. A monomial is kept if no polynomial in II has it as its leading term, its term of greatest weight. Otherwise II contains a polynomial whose other terms are kept monomials:

    xayb−∑s keptcs s ∈ I.x^ay^b-\sum_{s\ \text{kept}}c_s\,s\ \in\ I.

    If xaybx^ay^b is not a multiple of an earlier leading term, this polynomial is a generator of II. The kept monomials are not in II. There are nn of them, they form the staircase, and they are a basis of C[x,y]/I\CC[x,y]/I. The generators, one at each corner of the staircase, form the reduced Gröbner basis of II for this order [2, Ch. 2].

    Multiplication by xx and by yy on C[x,y]/I\CC[x,y]/I, in the basis of the staircase, are two commuting n×nn\times n matrices XX and YY. In the figure above, xx moves a box one step right and yy one step up; a monomial outside the staircase is a combination of boxes in C[x,y]/I\CC[x,y]/I. The joint eigenvalues of XX and YY are the points, a point of multiplicity kk counted kk times. The vector 11 is cyclic: the matrices applied to it span Cn\CC^n. Two commuting n×nn\times n matrices with a cyclic vector, up to a change of basis, are a point of Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) [7, Ch. 1].

    Colliding points

    When points collide, their ideal has a limit. As a point comes to another point pp along the direction vv, their ideal converges to (ℓv)+mp2(\ell_v)+\mathfrak m_p^2, where ℓv\ell_v is the equation of the line through pp along vv and mp\mathfrak m_p is the ideal of pp. This is the double point at pp with direction vv. The double points at one place form a projective line P1\PP^1, and Hilb⁡2(C2)\Hilb^2(\CC^2) is Sym⁡2(C2)\Sym^2(\CC^2) with its diagonal blown up.

    Three points that come together along a curve y=cx2+…y=cx^2+\dots through the origin converge to the curvilinear triple point

    (y−cx2, x3).\bigl(y-cx^2,\ x^3\bigr).

    Three points that come from three directions at once converge to mp2\mathfrak m_p^2. The disc above holds all the real triple points at one place: mp2\mathfrak m_p^2 at its centre, and the triple points along straight lines on its rim, where opposite points are the same.

    The torus and its fixed points

    tt

    The torus T=(C×)2T=(\CC^\times)^2 acts on the plane by scaling the coordinates, and so acts on Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2). For the weight w=(w1,w2)w=(w_1,w_2), the points move to the origin along t↦(tw1x, tw2y)t\mapsto(t^{w_1}x,\,t^{w_2}y) as tt goes from 11 to 00. Their ideal ItI_t converges to the initial ideal of II, generated by the terms of greatest weight of the generators [3, §15.8]:

    lim⁡t→0It=in⁡w(I).\lim_{t\to0}I_t=\init_w(I).

    The ticks on the dial of ww are the weights at which two terms of a generator weigh the same. For ww between two ticks, in⁡w(I)\init_w(I) is the monomial ideal of the staircase; for ww on a tick, it is not monomial.

    The points of Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) fixed by TT are the monomial ideals with nn monomials outside them, one for each partition of nn; the strip under the picture shows them. The points that flow to the same fixed point form a cell [1], so the Euler characteristic of Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) is the number of partitions of nn:

    ∑n≥0χ(Hilb⁡n(C2)) qn=∏k≥111−qk.\sum_{n\ge0}\chi\bigl(\Hilb^n(\CC^2)\bigr)\,q^n=\prod_{k\ge1}\frac{1}{1-q^k}.

    Its Betti numbers count the partitions by their number of rows, as the strip groups them: b2ib_{2i} is the number of partitions of nn into n−in-i rows [4].

    Tangent spaces at the fixed points

    The tangent space to Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) at the fixed point IλI_\lambda is Hom⁡(Iλ,C[x,y]/Iλ)\Hom(I_\lambda,\CC[x,y]/I_\lambda). It splits into weight spaces for TT: a homomorphism of weight (d1,d2)(d_1,d_2) takes each monomial xiyjx^iy^j of IλI_\lambda to a multiple of xi+d1yj+d2x^{i+d_1}y^{j+d_2}. Each box ss of the diagram of λ\lambda gives two weights [4; 6; 7, Ch. 5]. Its arm a(s)a(s) is the number of boxes to its right, and its leg l(s)l(s) the number of boxes above it, both grey in the figure; its weights are

    (−a(s)−1, l(s))and(a(s), −l(s)−1)\bigl(-a(s)-1,\ l(s)\bigr)\quad\text{and}\quad\bigl(a(s),\ -l(s)-1\bigr)

    In the figure each weight is an arrow from a monomial outside the diagram to one inside. So the tangent space has dimension 2n2n at every fixed point. Every point flows to a fixed point, and the dimension of the tangent space can only grow in a limit, so it is 2n2n everywhere: Hilb⁡n(C2)\Hilb^n(\CC^2) is smooth, of dimension 2n2n [5].

    References

    1. A. Białynicki-Birula, Some theorems on actions of algebraic groups. Ann. of Math. 98 (1973), 480–497
    2. D. Cox, J. Little, D. O’Shea, Ideals, varieties, and algorithms. Springer, 4th ed. (2015). Ch. 2 (Gröbner bases)
    3. D. Eisenbud, Commutative algebra with a view toward algebraic geometry. Graduate Texts in Mathematics 150, Springer (1995). §15.8 (initial ideals as flat limits)
    4. G. Ellingsrud, S. A. Strømme, On the homology of the Hilbert scheme of points in the plane. Invent. Math. 87 (1987), 343–352
    5. J. Fogarty, Algebraic families on an algebraic surface. Amer. J. Math. 90 (1968), 511–521
    6. M. Haiman, t,qt,q-Catalan numbers and the Hilbert scheme. Discrete Math. 193 (1998), 201–224
    7. H. Nakajima, Lectures on Hilbert schemes of points on surfaces. University Lecture Series 18, AMS (1999). Ch. 1 and 5